Goodbye, Love

We are shutting down Muddy Mint... kind of. Here's the story:

Back in January 2023, Troy & I had lunch with our landlords. We met up to talk about the space adjacent to our current soap studio and the possibility of renting it to expand our space. This move would have given us additional room, which is something we desperately needed to grow. During that meeting, we asked if we could sign a one-year lease for the adjacent space. Our landlords wanted us to sign a two-year lease. But something didn't feel right, and we were hesitant.

To take a step back, our business grew five times in 2020. In 2021 we moved from a 350 sq ft backyard studio to a 1500 sq ft building in downtown Longmont. After less than two years in our new space, we were already starting to feel squeezed and at the beginning of 2023, Troy and I began to talk more about the direction of Muddy Mint. We knew we couldn't keep making all the soap. After all, we had a business to manage! We had our processes fine-tuned, so 2023 would be the year we could finally hire soap makers, meaning we would need more room, not only for extra people but for more drums and larger equipment. We had a grand plan, which brings us back to why we were meeting with our landlords.

After we left that meeting, we had a lot of thinking to do. Troy and I proceeded to talk for over an hour. The real question was: why were we so reluctant to sign a two-year lease, given our plans? At first, we were thinking: we'll probably outgrow this space in two years and need a larger warehouse. That thought personally made me cringe. A warehouse? Ugh. The longer we talked and the further we dug, we realized that neither one of us wanted to run a large business.

It's hard to stop a moving train. Scaling up, hiring more people, creating more efficient processes - these are all part of growing a business. It's what is expected. But what if growth feels like something you have to do, rather than something you want to do? What if you want to keep things small?

I'm nearly 50 and Troy just turned 58 and we're both at the stage in our lives where spending time with the people we love is at the forefront of our minds. This hit me especially hard after Troy lost his mom last year. As a result, we would like to spend time with my parents while they're healthy, enjoy quality time with our kids before they head off into adulthood, take more time to visit extended family, host dinners with friends, spend time in nature, focus on our own health and well-being, and generally be more present in our lives with the people we care about.

As exciting as it has been to build Muddy Mint and watch us grow (we're on track to reach one of our big revenue milestones this year!), the thought of running a big soap company doesn't bring us the same joy. That said, it feels like a shame to get this far and throw it all away. We are still growing like crazy and so many people love our soap! It doesn't feel right to sell the business either. We worked hard to build our audience and we love our brand. Plus, Troy quit his architecture job to grow this thing with me and here we are wanting to stop?

As we sat and talked, we had an idea: "What if we give the business back to the people that made us?" All of you! Rather than selling to a person or company, what if we share everything we've learned? Generally, we're thinking of this as a pivot from soapmaking to education. We get so many questions every day from all of you about how to make soap, scaling your business, whether you should sell on Etsy or on your own website, how to make palm free soap, where to buy essential oils, etc. We absolutely love talking about soap, business, and helping other small businesses.

You've seen glimpses of this shift already with our YouTube channel and our recipe downloads. We'll still be making soap, but not very often. We will sell what we make, but it won't be anywhere near the volume we're making now. We're moving back to that 350 sq ft studio and we're simplifying and allowing ourselves to see where things go. We're coming back full circle, but with nearly eight years of experience. We'll still be around, but in a totally new way. 

We're not sure exactly what the future holds, but we do know this:

  • We are shutting down our wholesale completely. The last day to order wholesale will be Friday December 1, 2023. This is a hard thing to say and will be even harder to do. We worked so hard to grow our wholesale business. We are in over 600 retail shops and have nearly 300 reviews, every single one of them five-stars. We love our retailers and we've been so fortunate to work with amazing shops. We wish we could visit every single one of you and give you a hug.
  • We are canceling our quarterly subscription box. We will not be releasing a Holiday subscription box. We'll still make holiday scents, but you'll have to buy them like the old days. :) If you're currently a subscription box subscriber, your subscription will be canceled immediately. 
  • We are still making soap until mid-November, so the holiday season will be completely normal, and we have lots of soap for everyone (we hope!). If you want certain scents, make sure you get them because they might never come back!
  • We are shutting down for two weeks over the holidays (Dec 21 - Jan 3). We'll be resting. We're not sure how much soap we'll have when we open back up, but we will keep you all posted on exactly what we have left and what is going on.
  • We will re-open from Jan 4 until late February. We will likely not be making any more soap during this time, so there's a chance that we'll be completely out of stock of everything. We're not sure how it'll play out, but we're guessing there won't be much left. We may make some things in January, if it looks like we have excess supplies that we need to get rid of, but they might be random things. Mostly, we'll be selling what we have left and working on moving everything out of our current space.
  • We will move everything into our home studio by the end of February. We are also leaving on vacation for five-weeks starting March 1, so we won't be back until mid-April or so. 
  • We are clearing out a LOT of stuff! Over the next few months, we will be selling a LOT of things. If you want anything, particularly if you're local, please email or DM us. This includes most of our equipment, in addition to our soapmaking supplies.

What does next year look like?

  • Simi's Book is coming out in late May. We have a fun idea to do a "Soap-Along" via YouTube for every single recipe in the book after it comes out. We'll see if that happens, but we can't wait to share this book with you! It was a ton of work and we ended up putting a lot of things on the backburner that we wanted to do this year, but it'll be worth it. It's like a little piece of our heart going out to you. :)
  • We'll keep making YouTube Videos and we'll hopefully have a lot more going up in 2024. Feel free to send us suggestions on videos you'd like to see! 
  • We may create a Soapmaking Course. This is something we've wanted to do for a very long time, but it may take a while... we want to do it right!
  • We may do Quarterly Soap Releases. We'd love to keep all our retail customers supplied with Muddy Mint soap, if possible. Some of you are like old friends. There will be soap made as we work on these projects and we'll probably sell it, so if you're interested, sign up for our e-mail list to know when our soap drops happen!
  • We are Open to the Possibilities of what 2024 brings. While we'll primarily be focusing on re-connecting with our friends and family, we also want to stay connected with you. Things may change as the year goes on, but we hope you'll hang around for the ride. 

We've sat with this decision for nearly an entire year and have been through a gamut of emotions, but as the year comes to a close, we're really happy to have gone through the full year and we're also at peace with our decision. We let our employees know very early on, so they will be okay, and they support us. They've been such an amazing team, and we can't imagine finishing this year off without them.

So, that's the end of Muddy Mint, as we know it. But there's more in store. Just you wait.

Love you guys,
XOXO
Simi & Troy

46 comments

  • Hey Simi and Troy! I was sad reading about your downsize but I’m excited for what the next chapter may bring into your lives.

    I am considering renting your location from the landlord and bringing back A retail location there selling CBD products.

    I am interesting in speaking with you guys about all the stuff you would like to sell and we could just leave it in the location for me to use and continue the good vibes there you guys will leave behind.

    Give me a call at 720-676-2930

    Eric
  • I just discovered your soap before Christmas!! We were getting our Christmas trees in Damascus, VA and decided to do a bit of local shopping. I had been tossing around the idea of making soap and saw your soap in one of the stores in Damascus!! I loved the fact that your ingredients were simple and all natural!!! I have chemical and fragrance allergies and can never find a product that is pure and natural until I read the label on your soaps! So I bought a couple bars and came home and tried them and had soft hands on the first day of using your lovely product!! So I looked you up online and ordered more soap! Then I read that you are changing directions to stay small with your business and I say ‘Hats off to you’! I look forward to reading your book and learning to make soap and thank you so much for being willing to educate us to make good soap!!! My skin thanks you too!!! Blessings!!!

    Jennifer
  • Simi I have been buying your soap for years and it is my go-to gift for friends as well as for myself. Thanks for making such a great product and I wish you and Troy all the best on your next adventure. I will buy a bunch to add to my stash but all good things must come to an end I guess. Thanks for the inspiration to follow your gut and consider what is really important.

    Diane
  • The last day your website is open. I just had to come by and show some love! So bitter sweet! xo

    Sherry
  • I’m so sorry to hear this but at the same time happy for you to be at peace with this decision. I can truly connect with many aspects of your experience, I’m going on my 28th year in the soap business, navigating the ups and downs is difficult. Get a bigger space? Go back to a smaller space, hire people or not? All tough decisions. It’s not always an easy ride, but it’s one we love. Your soaps and photos are beautiful, I’ve admired your dedication to this business and understand the challenges of keeping it small and the difficulty in saying no when necessary. Making the right decision, especially in an industry where the craft becomes a part of who we are, is never easy. Kudos to you for taking that brave step, making that tough decision and prioritizing what’s best for you. I look forward to ordering your book and supporting you in your next steps! Best of luck to you in this new phase of your life, enjoy your vacation and time with your friends and family. XOXO, DeShawn

    DeShawn Marie

Leave a comment